Оценки Thief

GameStar – 8.9/10
Softpedia – 8.5/10
GameInformer – 8/10
CVG – 8/10
Joystiq – 8/10
Destructoid - 7.5/10
PlayStation Universe – 7.5/10
GameTrailers – 7.5/10
OXM – 7/10
OPM – 7/10
Edge – 7/10
Lazygamer – 6.9/10
Polygon – 6/10
Eurogamer – 6/10
gamesTM – 6/10
Gamespot – 6/10
ArabicGamers – 6.5/10
Kotaku – "Не стоит покупки"